Skip to content
Global 100 Forum

How well do AI detectors handle fiction and poetry?

Asked by Lena B. · AI text detection2 repliesupdated

Short answer

Most of what I read about detectors is about essays and web copy. I write other things too. Short stories, a few poems, some brand fiction for a client's newsletter. A client's editor ran one of my short pieces through a detector last week and sent me a screenshot with a big red number on it.

Written by Lena B. ·
CiteGlobal 100 Forum, "How well do AI detectors handle fiction and poetry?", https://global100.org/forum/q/how-well-do-ai-detectors-handle-fiction-and-poetry/, accessed 2026-11-21.
  1. Member ·

    I wrote it myself, in an afternoon, on my sofa. It has dialogue, a lot of short lines, a couple of fragments on purpose. That is my style.

    Two questions. Do detectors even work on creative writing, or are they built for essays? And does poetry break them completely, since it has line breaks and odd syntax and not much running prose? I would like to know what to say to an editor who thinks a number is a verdict. Preferably something I can back up with a source and not just my say-so.

    0
    ReplyLink

Plain text or simple Markdown. Links are nofollow. Your email is never shown.

  1. Priya N.Member ·

    I teach a creative writing section and I do not use them at all. The reason is practical: the features that make fiction good, voice, rhythm, surprise, are not the features a detector reads. A workshop where students read pages aloud and defend line choices tells me far more about who wrote a piece than any score.

    For your editor: the useful answer is not "my piece is fine", it is "here are my drafts and notes with dates".

  2. Lena B.Member ·

    @Priya N. the dated drafts are already on the sofa laptop. Fine, I will send them. Blunt version: if an editor needs a process folder to believe me, they can have the folder.

Global 100 Forum. Questions and answers on AI detection, deepfakes and content authenticity.